23rd May 2023
A recent decision, T 1158/20, of the EPO’s Technical Board of Appeal tells us that hosting oral proceedings by videoconference can be, for some cases, an equivalent alternative to in-person oral proceedings.
18th Apr 2023
Almost all EPO opposition hearings are now conducted by videoconference (VICO). VICO opposition hearings have been very successful and are no doubt here to stay. In general, the EPO will insist that opposition hearings are carried out by VICO unless there are exceptional reasons for an in-person hearing. Only two VICO hearings have been changed from VICO to be in-person in the last three years.
13th Oct 2022
A petition for review is a way to challenge the final decision of the Technical Board of Appeal (“the TBA”) of the EPO. Since December 2007, when petitions for review were first made an available recourse, only 9 of 191 petitions succeeded – that is, resulted in the decision under review being set aside – putting the overall hit-rate at 4.7%. Clearly, the petitioner is rarely triumphant.
21st Apr 2022
The EPO has recently extended the pilot program for oral proceedings by videoconference (VICO) before opposition divisions until 31 December 2022. This means that opposition oral proceedings will continue to be held by VICO until the end of this year, unless there are serious reasons not to.
16th Jul 2021
Following the oral proceedings that took place two weeks’ ago, the EPO’s Enlarged Board of Appeal has today (16 July 2021) given its answer to the referred question in case G1/21 – whether oral proceedings can be held by video conference without the consent of the parties.
2nd Jul 2021
Oral proceedings in case G1/21 took place today (2 July 2021) for the second time in case, after proceedings were adjourned at the first oral proceedings that took place last month. While we don’t know what the outcome of the oral proceedings will be, the proceedings were at least properly concluded and we can expect the written decision in due course.
11th Jun 2021
In their recent decision (T1839/18), the boards of appeal re-affirmed the legality of straw man oppositions. Although this in itself is not news, we felt it offered a good opportunity to look again at the many advantages of anonymously opposing a European patent.
28th May 2021
The oral proceedings before the Enlarged Board of Appeal to discuss the question of whether oral proceedings by video conference can be appointed without the consent of the parties was held (by video conference) today. However, we are still no closer to finding out whether video conference can be used for all oral proceedings without […]